top of page

The Maastricht Diplomat

MD-fulltext-logo.png
  • 1200px-Facebook_f_logo_(2019).svg
  • Instagram_logo_2016.svg

The Paradoxes of Romanticisation

20 hours ago
5 min read

Updated: 4 hours ago

When Does Idyllic Escapism Become a Social Issue?


Photo by Tamara Urigová
Photo by Tamara Urigová

We have all been there. Returning home after a hectic day, with our mind unhelpfully enumerating the unread emails that continue to haunt our inbox and the tasks that obstinately evade completion. If good fortune chooses to intervene, we may discover a few leftovers in the fridge and, with some imagination, repurpose them as dinner. Then we succumb to the siren call of the algorithm and let precious hours slip by in the cosy company of our screen, too tired to do otherwise. 

 

Luckily for us, an internet trend is coming to our rescue, ensuring that the potential of a random Wednesday evening does not pass unnoticed: romanticisation. 

 

Over the past few years, romanticisation  has woven its way into my consciousness and transformed the way I go about my everyday life. The aesthetic language of romanticisation informs the way I take pictures of candid moments with friends over steaming cups of tea. Or it encourages me to compose a list of seasonal activities that I wish to experience this autumn. Even putting on some atmospheric music to accompany a particularly dreary study session is done with the intention of romanticising. The romantic has become something of a shield against scenarios like the one described above.

 

However, a new development in my life introduced some cracks into my romantic dream and forced me to reflect more seriously on the implications of this seemingly innocuous trend: beginning university. It was a rather difficult pill to swallow when nothing looked or felt exactly like the Pinterest mood board that I had diligently curated over the summer. My romanticised vision of a warm cocoa keeping me company late at night as I pore over heaps of books strewn across the table met with the harsh reality of reading endless PDF documents until my temples throb from the blue light of my screen, wishing my housemates were less nocturnal and played their music quietly.

 

And so, questions began to arise: Is romanticisation truly helping me reckon with the mundaneness of everyday life or does it only make me sink deeper into disillusionment? And when does idyllic escapism surpass the realms of personal choice and become a societal concern? I chose to investigate. 

...

 

The Anatomy of Romanticisation

 

First, we must delve into, what I would call, the philosophy of romanticisation. It may not come as a great surprise that the Romantic movement can be credited with the expression to romanticise, which first sprang from the pen of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, a famous British poet, in 1818. Traces of the deeply subjective, the emotionally-charged, and the transcendental, which captured the imaginations of 19th century Romantic artists, may be seen in our current approach to romanticisation: the personal striving to overcome the barriers separating us from a richer and more profound experience of our daily lives. Who knows, maybe the old Romantics would have heartily approved of baking sourdough bread from scratch as opposed to getting a bag of toasts from the nearest supermarket...

 

Despite its etymological link to the Romantic movement, romanticisation as a social media phenomenon has its distinct agenda, which I like to think of as the three Ss: slower, smaller, simpler. These three core values position romanticisation as the antidote to the productivity-oriented hustle culture which is so intrinsically embedded in the neoliberal labour market. Hustle culture’s insistence on relentless self-optimisation and efficient time allocation, often at the expense of personal wellbeing, has left exhaustion and disillusionment in its wake. 

 

To these, romanticisation provides a clear alternative: it encourages us to radically redefine our source of fulfilment and meaning. This means slowing down and remaining present when we feel rushed, transforming routines into intentional practices when we feel oppressed by repetition, or savouring the beauty found in the mundane when we feel like our days are irreversibly slipping away.   Romanticisation is an attempt at a cultural correction of our society’s obsession with productivity and efficiency, which bulldoze over the fragile simplicity of everyday life. 

 

Lofty ideals aside, I believe that a philosophy, especially one concerned with how we structure and perceive our daily lives, is only as good as its practical applications (after all, we do not want to indulge in a romanticised vision of romanticisation). From my experience as a citizen of the internet, I have identified three contradictions or paradoxes at the heart of romanticisation, the acknowledgement of which is not intended as a denunciation of the trend, but as means through which I hope to make my engagement with it more mindful and nuanced. It is a way of seeing my personal activity on the internet through a broader societal lens. 


Romanticisation in Paradoxes

 

Paradox the First: (Do not) Go Analog. As we already discovered, romanticisation forgrounds the idea of paying attention to all the loveliness found in the common-place and summoning it like a Genie from a bottle. This mindfulness approach is often expressed through the endorsement of so-called analog activities, meaning activities that allow us toescape the glare of omnipresent screen light and immerse ourselves into more tactile experiences that soothe our racing minds. Baking, crocheting, gardening, journaling, hiking, reading... the list is extensive. However, one thing strikes me as odd: if we were truly successful at romanticisation, should not we feel disinclined from posting about these reclaimed moments of inner tranquillity online? Is not that precisely what we are trying to escape? Sometimes, I cannot help but feel that by consuming content about other people disengaging from digital technologies, I only ensure my own continued engagement with them. The second-hand experience of candlelit rooms, warm blankets, and stormy nights presented to me in 20 second video clips is enough to placate my mind into judging my internet activity less harshly. I confess, I delegate a significant portion of my romanticisation to content creators, and I suspect I might not be the only one.

 

Paradox the Second: Endurance, not Solution. I recently caught myself thinking: I might be sitting down to my assignments with a cosy cup of tea, wrapped up in a knitted sweater that I rescued from a thrift shop in accordance with the dictates of romanticisation, but,ultimately, I do not feel any less rushed or overwhelmed. If anything, I feel the combined pressure of achieving a productive performance in an aesthetically pleasing way. This is doubtlessly in part a personal failing, yet it made me question the manner in which romanticisation is sometimes employed: as a means of enduring our productivity-oriented lifestyles, disguising hustle-culture under a veneer of mindfulness, rather than systematically addressing the issue of overworking on a societal level. The pressure to optimise and maximise remains intact. 

 

Paradox the Third: Aesthetics and the Algorithm. Critics of romanticisation denounce the trend as overly performative. Conversely, content creators who view romanticisation favourably counter this accusation by emphasising that aesthetics are, and always should be, secondary to the main goal of achieving a more contented life. The truth of the matter remains that social media are governed by the invisible hand of the algorithm which is known to favour more aesthetically pleasing content that secures greater audience engagement (and thus revenue for the platforms). And so, we are presented with a highly curated vision of what romanticisation could and should look like, setting a characteristically impossible standard for mere mortals to meet.

...

To romanticise, or not to romanticise? That is not the question. There is nothing inherently liberating nor inherently harmful in sprinkling a little romantic sentiment into our days. A philosophy is only as sound as its applications, and the applications of romanticisation in our personal lives are entirely at our command. I only invite you to remain curious about the broader picture than that which fits onto our mobile phone screens. 

 

 

Comments


Email Address: journal@myunsa.org

Copyright 2020 UNSA | All rights reserved UNSA

powered-by-unsa.png
bottom of page