Trinity Syndrome and Female Portrayal in Film
Think of a powerful, fictional female character – chances are she spends her whole lifetime training to become the very best in her field, only to be eclipsed by a male protagonist. This is a phenomenon called “Trinity Syndrome,” coined by film critic Tasha Robinson, who gave the name in relation to Trinity from The Matrix (1999). After making the point that Trinity, among many other capable female characters, never becomes as significant and relevant as they are in their introductory scene.
Trinity Syndrome
Since the victimized, trophy portrayal of women in 1980s films, there has been a cultural push to move away from sexualized, infantilized depictions of women and instead lean into personalities with their own purpose and meaning. The film industry shows an increase in ‘meaningful’ female characters, though it is sometimes difficult to find real depictions of equality or inclusion. These characters often add little to the plot and seem to exist only to create the illusion of feminism while undermining it.
A popular example of this pattern can be seen in Hermione Granger from Harry Potter (2001), who is initially portrayed as a ‘best in her class’ and a witch with unparalleled capabilities, in heavy contrast to Harry. Throughout the saga, however, she falls more and more into the background of the plot and confines most of her efforts to helping ‘the chosen one ’, Harry, with his own agenda. Her own capabilities, which to the end still seem to have the upper hand on Harry's, can be no rival to the depressing truth of his divine powers. This view, however, is contested, as some readers argue she is the core reason for the trio's survival on multiple occasions. The issue with this counterargument is that it further backs the idea that although her own abilities are far superior to those of Harry, he still ‘wins’ in the end by being the chosen one.
Following the trope of a female character with subordinated purpose is Wyldstyle from The Lego Movie (2014), who is portrayed as more confident and more capable than her protagonist, Emmet. In contrast to her powerful introduction, she spends the majority of the plot being rescued repeatedly and gives Emmet her seal of approval in the end, giving him the ratification he longs for. Robinson even identifies the ending of the movie in which Wyldstyle ‘asks’ for permission to break up with her current boyfriend, Batman. In this scene, he ‘gives’ her his blessing to go to Emmet, as if she were a grand prize which could be constantly passed around to whoever is the ultimate hero.
Woman as Image, Man as Bearer of the Look
These portrayals fall in line with the roots of the ‘male gaze’ defined by filmmaker Laura Mulvey in 1975 in an essay titled “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema,”. Both conceptions address women as existing only in relation to a male lead- one being through the camera and the other through the storyline progression. In her essay, she critiques Hollywood cinema and its patriarchal depictions and representations of women, explaining how films are shot through the lens of standard, male, heterosexual viewers. This can be seen through frames which linger on female bodies with the aim of sexual magnetism (the passivity of being looked at), whereas the males lead in action and solve the problems (active looking). The women on screen effectively have two functions: the exhibitionist role for the character in the film, as well as for the spectators of the film. The twofold purpose can also be observed in male characters, for whom viewers of the film might hold the same idea of the erotic look, though through a different lens- one having much more to do with a masculine ego. The purpose of these characters is to seem as attainable as possible to the viewer.

Image 1 - Quote from Mulvey on the Male Gaze
What both critics have in common, aside from the fact that they’re both women, is that the underlying issue is that female characters aren't given significant purpose in a story. While the days of frail, helpless women in movies might be long gone, in the end, their capabilities still have no determinative meaning, as their purpose is to stand aside while the male protagonist pursues their quest to become ‘the chosen one’. What is especially concerning is the abundance of examples of Trinity Syndrome in pieces catered to a younger audience. Aside from Hermione and Wyldstyle, the effect can be observed in countless other pieces such as Colette Tatou in Ratatouille (2007), Master Tigress in Kung Fu Panda (2008), and Valka in How to Train Your Dragon 2 (2014). The danger, and core issue, is that young, impressionable minds, both male and female, see these portrayals growing up and subliminally absorb them into their worldviews and the way they perceive themselves, especially in relation to those of the other gender.
While Trinity Syndrome cannot be applied to all skillful female characters, and the increase in ‘significant’ female characters is considerable to note, there is a clear distinction between portraying women as strong and actually allowing them to exercise their strength. One study found an increase in powerful female characters from 27 percent in 2002 to just under 32 percent in 2016. This progress represents a step in the right direction; however, this alone does not amount to complete equality in the media, specifically film. The industry needs to move forward and not only provide strong women, but also to assert them with their own narratives fueled by their own ambitions and achievements. Representation is not simply about having a strong female character; it's about allowing her to be the hero herself.





Comments